The 5 Best Tea Places in Indianapolis, IN

According to recent research, Indianapolis has over 310 places to enjoy tea. While the options are abundant, not all tea establishments offer the same quality.

In this article, we will explore the top 5 tea spots in the city. We won’t limit ourselves to traditional tea houses. We’ll also highlight regular cafes and even coffee houses where you can enjoy an exceptional cup of tea.

1. Rustic Root

Rustic Root
Source: Wendy R. (via Yelp)

Rustic Root is a tea room and café situated in Beech Grove, Indiana, offering an experience reminiscent of a country cottage with its shabby-chic decor. The atmosphere is quaint and welcoming, designed to evoke a sense of stepping into a storybook setting. The café features various dining areas, each decorated to provide a cozy and intimate dining experience, making it a suitable choice for those seeking a quiet corner for tea or a comfortable space for gatherings.

The centerpiece of Rustic Root’s offering is its extensive tea selection. With over 15 types of tea, the menu caters to a wide range of tastes, from traditional blends to more unique flavors. The tea service is complemented by an assortment of sandwiches, salads, scones, and desserts, served in a traditional high tea fashion on three-tiered trays. This approach to dining emphasizes the tea experience, with detailed attention given to the preparation and presentation of each pot of tea.

Beyond its focus on tea, Rustic Root also offers a variety of other menu items, including breakfast and lunch options. The café aims to create a memorable experience through its food and drink, with an emphasis on quality and detail. The space doubles as a gift shop, featuring handmade items and home decor, adding an additional element of charm to the visit.

Located in a community-oriented part of Beech Grove, Rustic Root serves as a gathering spot for those looking to enjoy a moment of tranquility or celebrate special occasions. It’s a place where the simple pleasure of a well-steeped tea takes precedence, set against a backdrop that feels both nostalgic and inviting.


  • Great atmosphere and decor
  • Variety of teas and food options
  • Excellent service
  • Unique and enjoyable experience


  • Couldn’t find any

Location: 626 Main St, Beech Grove, IN 46107

2. Ms. B’s Teas

Ms. B’s Teas
Source: Ms. B’s Teas (via Yelp)

Ms. B’s Teas is a tea room, bistro, and bouTEAque located in the downtown area of Clayton, Indiana. Owned and operated by a local woman, this establishment focuses on creating a space for individuals to enjoy a variety of teas, coffees, and food in a welcoming atmosphere.

At the heart of Ms. B’s Teas is its wide selection of teas. Customers can choose from traditional options like the London Fog to more unique blends such as Persimmon Peach and Butterscotch Black Tea, each served in individual teapots with traditional cups. The tea menu includes flavors to suit a range of palates, including a Lemongrass Vanilla blend among other seasonal selections.

The food menu at Ms. B’s Teas is designed to complement the tea experience, with options available for various dietary preferences, including vegan choices. The Tea for Two and Tea for One offerings feature tiered towers filled with an assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and mini desserts. For those looking for something more substantial, the menu also includes quiches, soups, and sandwiches.

The interior of Ms. B’s Teas combines elements of classic and contemporary design, creating a relaxed setting. Staff are known for their friendly service, contributing to the establishment’s reputation as a comfortable place for breakfast, lunch, or afternoon tea. While the tea room is appreciated for its quality offerings and the experience it provides, visitors also value the sense of community it fosters.


  • Friendly and welcoming staff
  • Delicious tea and food options
  • Quaint and cozy ambiance
  • Good variety of teas


  • Service can be slow

Location: 4883 Iowa St, Clayton, IN 46118

3. Tea’s Me Cafe

Tea's Me Cafe
Source: Jackie M. (via Yelp)

Tea’s Me Cafe, located on the near northside of Indianapolis, has established itself as a notable destination for tea lovers since its opening in 2001. The cafe offers a wide array of teas and tisanes from around the globe, making it a go-to spot for those seeking quality and variety in their tea choices. With over 40 different types of tea available, patrons have the opportunity to explore a range of flavors and blends, guided by the knowledgeable staff who are well-versed in the nuances of tea.

In addition to its focus on tea, Tea’s Me Cafe also serves a selection of food items, including breakfast wraps, sandwiches, and salads. The menu highlights include a chicken salad sandwich and a pesto chicken sandwich on a croissant, complemented by various soup options. For those looking for a refreshing drink, the pomegranate blueberry tea is among the popular choices.

Situated between the Herron-Morton Place and Fall Creek Place neighborhoods, the cafe benefits from a location that is both accessible and community-oriented. It features seating both indoors and outdoors, catering to different preferences, whether patrons are looking for a quiet place to enjoy tea or a space to work and meet with others.

The cafe’s engagement with the local community is also reflected in its support for local artists, with artwork displayed inside, adding to the ambiance. Tea’s Me Cafe aims to provide a welcoming atmosphere, where the service is attentive and the environment conducive to relaxation and conversation.

For those interested in a diverse selection of teas and a menu that offers both light and hearty options, Tea’s Me Cafe presents itself as a space where quality tea and good food can be enjoyed in a comfortable setting.


  • Extensive tea selection
  • Friendly and knowledgeable staff
  • Delicious food, particularly sandwiches
  • Welcoming and pleasant atmosphere


  • Couldn’t find any.

Location: 140 E 22nd St, Ste B, Indianapolis, IN 46202

4. Sassafras Tea Room

Sassafras Tea Room
Source: Cassandra D. (via Yelp)

Sassafras Tea Room, situated in Greenwood, Indiana, has been serving the community since 2010, offering a serene spot for tea enthusiasts and those looking for a quaint dining experience. This tea room is housed in an older two-story home, providing a blend of historical charm and a welcoming atmosphere for various gatherings, including lunches, birthday parties, bridal and baby showers, rehearsal dinners, and small weddings.

Central to Sassafras Tea Room’s appeal is its extensive selection of teas. Patrons can choose from a variety of black, green, and herbal teas, along with distinctive flavored blends such as Almond Shortbread. The tea service, complete with unique teapots and cups, adds to the room’s overall charm and offers a personalized touch to the tea-drinking experience.

The menu also features a range of carefully prepared dishes. Among the notable offerings is the crustless quiche, filled with feta cheese, spinach, and sun-dried tomatoes, and topped with hollandaise sauce. It is accompanied by a side salad dressed in a raspberry vinaigrette and a scone, aiming to provide a balanced and enjoyable meal.

While the ambiance of dining in a historic home adds to the experience, the focus at Sassafras Tea Room is on creating a peaceful setting where guests can enjoy good food and tea. The staff’s attention to service contributes to the welcoming environment, ensuring a pleasant visit for everyone.

Sassafras Tea Room stands as a reflection of the community’s appreciation for relaxed dining experiences and the timeless tradition of tea, making it a notable spot in Greenwood for both special occasions and everyday visits.


  • Great venue for small gatherings and special occasions
  • Delicious food, especially the quiche and chicken salad
  • Variety of tasty teas
  • Good service overall
  • Charming and quaint ambiance


  • Couldn’t find any.

Location: 229 N Madison Ave, Greenwood, IN 46142

5. Tilly’s Tea Room

Tilly's Tea Room
Source: Julie K. (via Yelp)

Tilly’s Tea Room, located on the third floor of Saks Fifth Avenue at the Fashion Mall in Indianapolis, is a venue where visitors can enjoy a selection of teas and a variety of dining options. The tea room’s focus on tea is evident in its extensive menu, which includes a range of traditional and unique blends. The Mango Green Tea, for example, has a subtle flavor, appealing to those who appreciate nuanced tastes in their tea.

The menu also features traditional afternoon tea offerings, such as freshly baked scones accompanied by clotted cream and a choice of English jam or lemon curd. For guests looking for more than just tea and scones, Tilly’s provides options like the Afternoon Tea set, which includes tea sandwiches, scones, and mini desserts, and the Pair Two option, allowing for a customized combination of a salad and sandwich.

The atmosphere at Tilly’s aims to be both stylish and comfortable, with decor that creates an inviting space for guests. Background music and the layout of the seating are designed to enhance the experience, making it suitable for a range of occasions. The staff is recognized for their attentiveness and expertise, contributing to the overall positive experience of visiting Tilly’s.

In addition to the food and tea, Tilly’s Tea Room offers tea-related merchandise, such as tea sets and jams, for those interested in taking a piece of their tea room experience home with them. Positioned as a place for both special events and casual visits, Tilly’s Tea Room offers an accessible experience for tea enthusiasts and those looking for a pleasant dining option in Indianapolis.


  • Excellent service
  • Pleasant atmosphere and decor
  • Wide variety of tea and food options
  • Special options for children
  • Accommodating to special occasions and dietary needs


  • Slow service at times
  • Limited options for vegetarians

Location: 8701 Keystone Crossing, Fl 3, Indianapolis, IN 46240

Similar Posts